When work simply disappears

Listen to the AI-generated audio version of this article. (Beta)

You’ve spent three weeks working on a concept. Then a short message arrives: the project won’t be moving forward for now. Other priorities.

Maybe you’ve been sending out the same report every Friday for months and have started to wonder who actually reads it. There’s no criticism, but there are no questions either. In fact, there’s no reaction at all.

Nothing about your job has formally changed. You’re still being paid, your responsibilities are the same, and you may even be just as busy as before. And yet, over time, some things can start to feel harder. You begin later, check your work less carefully, or take longer with things that once came easily.

Two experiments show surprisingly well why this can happen.

Eleven Figures Versus Seven

Dan Ariely and two colleagues asked students to build small Lego figures. They received two dollars for the first figure and a little less for each one after that. They could continue for as long as they wanted and stop whenever they chose.

For one group, the completed figures stayed on the table. With each round, they could see what they had already accomplished. For the other group, the experimenter took apart a completed figure as soon as the participant started building the next one. The pieces went back into the box and were later used again.

The task was the same for both groups, and so was the payment. Yet there was a clear difference. Participants whose figures remained on the table built around eleven on average. The others completed only about seven and stopped earlier.

The researchers called this second condition “Sisyphus,” after the figure from Greek mythology who repeatedly pushes a stone up a hill, only to watch it roll back down again. What mattered was not that the work had become more difficult, or that anyone had criticized it. It simply kept disappearing in front of the people who had just completed it.

Two Seconds of Attention

In a second experiment, the researchers looked at something even closer to everyday office life. Participants were given sheets filled with long strings of letters and asked to find particular combinations. Once again, the payment decreased with each additional task.

This time, there were three conditions. In the first, participants wrote their names on the sheet. When they were finished, the experimenter took it, looked over it briefly, nodded and placed it on a pile. There was no praise and no comment.

In the second group, the experimenter also took the sheet but placed it on the pile immediately, without looking at it. In the third, the sheet was fed directly into a shredder in front of the participant.

You might expect the shredder to make the biggest difference. What was more surprising, however, was how similarly the second and third groups behaved. Whether the work was placed on a pile without being looked at or destroyed immediately made far less difference to people’s willingness to continue than you might expect.

The largest gap was between those groups and the one whose work had been briefly acknowledged. Those participants kept working for longer, in some cases even when there was almost nothing left to earn. There had been no praise and no detailed feedback. A brief look and a nod had been enough.

What Remains of This in the Office

In everyday working life, of course, people rarely destroy someone’s work in front of them. But work can disappear in far less dramatic ways.

A concept is sent by email and never mentioned again. Figures are prepared for a presentation, but you never find out whether they were actually used. A project is stopped after weeks of work without anyone explaining what led to the decision.

Usually, there’s no bad intention behind this. Perhaps the report was read, the analysis was useful, and the concept genuinely influenced a decision. The person who did the work simply never hears about it.

Over time, that can make a difference. If you never know what became of your work, it becomes harder to judge its value. Why spend the extra half hour? Why revise a sentence for the third time if you never find out whether anyone even read that far?

This usually doesn’t happen consciously. You don’t wake up one morning and decide to give only eighty percent from now on. Instead, a feeling gradually develops that the extra effort doesn’t seem to make any visible difference.

Recognition May Require Less Than We Think

What makes the second experiment especially interesting is how little was needed. The experimenter didn’t praise the participants or tell them their work was especially important. He simply looked at the sheet, reacted briefly, and put it aside.

Perhaps recognition at work is sometimes made more complicated than it needs to be. Not every task requires elaborate praise. Often, a small piece of feedback is enough to show someone that their work actually reached another person.

“We used the figures in your appendix yesterday to make the decision.”

“We’re taking your second proposal into the next version.”

“We’re not moving forward with the project, but your analysis showed us that the effort isn’t worth it at the moment.”

These are not grand gestures. But they communicate something that a general “Thanks, looks good” does not necessarily convey: someone actually paid attention. At the same time, they answer a question that can otherwise remain open: What happened to my work?

Even a Rejected Project Can Still Have an Outcome

Just because something isn’t implemented doesn’t automatically mean the work was pointless. Concepts are rejected, campaigns are stopped, presentations are never given, and priorities shift. In organisations, that is part of normal working life.

The problem is more often that no one explains how the decision was reached. Someone who spends three weeks on an idea and is only told that the topic will not be pursued has a very different experience from someone who hears: “Your analysis showed that the market is currently too small, so we’re stopping here.”

The outcome is the same in both cases. The project ends. But in the second case, the person at least knows what role their work played in the decision.

Perhaps that is the important difference from the Sisyphus experiment. Not everything we work on has to remain visibly on the table. But it helps to know why it is no longer there.

When You’re the One Hearing Very Little Back

If you’ve noticed that certain tasks have started to feel harder, or that you’re putting less energy into them than you used to, it may be worth looking at the feedback surrounding that work. Do you actually know what happens to the things you hand over? Do you find out which of them are useful and which are not?

Sometimes, a simple question is enough. What happened to the concept? Was the analysis useful? Is the report still needed, or should it be changed? Those questions don’t have to sound accusatory. Often, feedback is missing simply because no one realised that the other person needed it.

It can also help to make the effect of your own work a little more visible. Not with a complicated productivity system, but perhaps with a short note at the end of the week: What did I finish? Which decision did I help prepare? Who did I make something easier for? What is different today compared with Monday?

That doesn’t replace feedback from other people. But it can stop the week from feeling like a collection of tasks that simply vanished the moment you sent them.

This Week: Really Look Once

If someone sends you something over the next few days that took time and effort, try responding to one of those things with something a little more specific than “Thanks” or a thumbs-up.

It doesn’t have to be praise. One sentence is enough to show that you genuinely looked at it: “The structure on page three helped me” or “The figure in the second section was important for the decision.”

Then you can ask the same question in the other direction. Think of something you handed over in the past few weeks and never heard about again. Ask what happened to it.

The answer may be completely unremarkable. But at least you’ll know where your work ended up.

Feedback

Terms of use

Terms of use for the use of the Mindvise platform for online psychological counseling

Date of last update: 20.05.2025

1. Service description
Mindvise provides a digital platform that gives company employees access to online psychological counseling by qualified, freelance psychologists. The psychologists act independently and determine the content of the consultations themselves.

2. Qualification of consultants
All consultants working on the platform have at least a degree in psychology (Master of Science or diploma). Their suitability is checked by Mindvise before they start working.

3. Confidentiality
All contents of the counseling sessions are subject to confidentiality. Personal information will not be passed on to third parties, in particular to the employer, except in the case of express consent or legal obligation.

4. Disclaimer
Use of the platform is voluntary and at your own risk. Psychological counseling is not a substitute for medical or psychotherapeutic treatment. Mindvise accepts no liability for direct or indirect consequences arising from the use of counseling services.

5. Code of conduct
Respectful, professional interaction is a prerequisite. Discrimination, insults or behavior that violates boundaries will not be tolerated. The advisors are entitled to terminate conversations in the event of inappropriate behavior.

6. Cancellation policy
Consultation appointments must be canceled at least 12 hours before the start. If an appointment is canceled later, up to 80% of the fee can be claimed as expenses, depending on the employer’s regulations.

7. Restrictions on use
Use is not suitable if:

* You are in an acute mental health crisis or emergency. In such cases, please contact the medical on-call service (116117) or the emergency number 112.
* You have a serious mental illness that requires continuous specialist care.
* You are a minor and do not have the consent of your legal guardian.

If you are currently undergoing psychotherapeutic treatment, we recommend that you consult with your treating specialist before using the platform.

8. Consent to data processing
By using the platform, you agree to the terms of use and the privacy policy. You agree that your voluntarily submitted information on mental stress may be processed by Mindvise (including health data in accordance with Art. 9 GDPR). This consent is voluntary and can be revoked at any time.

If you have any questions or concerns, please contact:
[kontakt@mindvise.de](mailto:kontakt@mindvise.de)

Privacy policy

1. General information on data protection

Thank you for using our services. The protection of your personal data is important to us. This privacy policy explains how we process personal data, when you use our services. We only collect the data that is necessary for the use of our platform, and do not pass it on to third parties without your consent.

2. Person responsible for data processing

Responsible within the meaning of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR):

Mindvise
Pascal Seitz
Lamprecht Str. 51
63739 Aschaffenburg, Germany

Phone: 01579-2526192
E-mail: kontakt@mindvise.de
Website: https://mental.mindvise.de

3. Collection and use of personal data

We only collect the data provided by you (first name, e-mail address, telephone number, business code, consultation topic, additional information transmitted on the consultation request) that was transmitted when booking consultation appointments. This data is stored on our server for 30 days and then backed up locally for 12 months. Our freelance consultants receive your data when an appointment is booked and also store it locally for a maximum of 12 months. For service agreements with a limit on monthly consultations per employee, the data is used to monitor compliance with the set limits.

4. Booking via hotline

As an alternative to online booking, you have the option of booking appointments via the hotline listed above so that you do not have to enter any data via the booking system.

5. Voluntariness of use

Use of the advisory services via the platform is voluntary. There are no disadvantages if you do not wish to take advantage of the offer.

6. Legal basis of the processing

Your data is processed on the following legal bases:

  • Consent (Art. 6 para. 1 lit. a GDPR): Your voluntary consent when providing the data for booking appointments.
  • Fulfillment of a contract (Art. 6 para. 1 lit. b GDPR): Processing of data for the provision of our services.
  • Protection of legitimate interests (Art. 6 para. 1 lit. f GDPR): Data processing is carried out in the interest of the smooth operation of our services, provided that no interests of the data subject worthy of protection prevail.

7. Processing of special categories of data

As part of the consultation, information may be processed that allows conclusions to be drawn about your mental health (e.g. through free text information on stress or concerns). This data is considered special categories of personal data within the meaning of Art. 9 GDPR. The processing takes place exclusively with your express consent in accordance with Art. 9 para. 2 lit. a GDPR. This consent is voluntary and can be revoked at any time.

8. Video communication

For video communication, we recommend using Jitsi Meet on our server at https://meet.mindvise.de. Advisors are free to decide whether to use this server or choose an alternative platform, which will be communicated to you in advance by e-mail. In this case, the data protection provisions of the chosen provider apply. If you do not wish to use an alternative provider as a video communication tool, you can communicate this by sending an e-mail to the selected consultant in advance. When using the Mindvise-hosted Jitsi Meet instance, personal data such as IP addresses may be collected. This data is used exclusively to enable communication and is not passed on to third parties.

9. Mental Health Assistent (ChatGPT API)

When using the digital mental health assistant, your voluntary free text entries can be transmitted to the OpenAI API for processing. The processing is pseudonymized (without direct name or identity assignment) and exclusively for the provision of the assistant function. The transfer is secured by the conclusion of standard contractual clauses in accordance with Art. 46 GDPR and OpenAI’s participation in the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework.

10. Technical and organizational measures (TOMs)

We have implemented the following measures to ensure the protection of your data:

  • Access control: The servers are provided by ISO-certified providers (Netcup, Alfahosting).
  • Access control: Access is only granted via password-protected systems with strict password guidelines.
  • Encryption and data backup: All data transmissions are SSL-encrypted. Data is deleted every 30 days and backed up locally.
  • Forwarding control: Encrypted communication channels (e-mail, SSL) are used.
  • Separation control: Logical separation of test and production data.
  • Integrity control: Regular backups and version controls ensure data integrity.
  • Roles and rights system: Administrative access is restricted; there is no access to personal content.

11 Rights of the data subjects

You have the right, to request information about the personal data stored about you at any time and to request the correction, deletion or restriction of the processing of this data. You also have the right to data portability and the right to object. You can withdraw your consent to the processing of personal data at any time.

12. Right to erasure (“right to be forgotten”)

You have the right to request the deletion of your personal data if:

  • the data is no longer required for the original purpose;
  • You withdraw your consent and there is no other legal basis for processing;
  • You object to the processing and there are no overriding legitimate grounds;
  • the data was processed unlawfully;
  • the deletion is necessary to fulfill a legal obligation.

13. Right to lodge a complaint with the supervisory authority

If you believe that the processing of your data violates the GDPR, you have the right to lodge a complaint with the competent data protection authority:

The Bavarian State Commissioner for Data Protection
P.O. Box 22 12 19, 80502 Munich
E-mail: poststelle@datenschutz-bayern.de

14. Duration of data storage

Personal data is stored on our server for a maximum of 30 days. At the end of this period, the data is deleted and backed up locally. Freelance consultants store the data locally for up to 12 months and then delete it permanently.

15. Data transfer to third parties and third countries

We do not pass on personal data to third parties without your consent. Personal data is only transferred to third countries in the context of using the Mental Health Assistant. In this case, the transfer is secured by OpenAI’s participation in the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework and by standard contractual clauses (SCCs) in accordance with Art. 46 GDPR.

16. Cookies and similar technologies

We only use technically necessary cookies on our website to enable you to make optimum use of our services. Analytical or marketing cookies are not used.

17. Automated decision-making including profiling

There is no automated decision-making or profiling within the meaning of Art. 22 GDPR.

18. Further processing for other purposes

Further processing of the personal data collected for other purposes is not planned. Should this become necessary in the future, you will be informed accordingly prior to such further processing.

19. Time of provision of the information

This information is provided to you at the latest at the time of data collection and within one month of the data being collected.

20. Adjustments to this privacy policy

We reserve the right to amend this privacy policy if necessary, to comply with legal requirements or to reflect changes to our services.

Feedback

Terms of use

Terms of use for the use of the Mindvise platform for online psychological counseling

Date of last update: 20.05.2025

1. Service description
Mindvise provides a digital platform that gives company employees access to online psychological counseling by qualified, freelance psychologists. The psychologists act independently and determine the content of the consultations themselves.

2. Qualification of consultants
All consultants working on the platform have at least a degree in psychology (Master of Science or diploma). Their suitability is checked by Mindvise before they start working.

3. Confidentiality
All contents of the counseling sessions are subject to confidentiality. Personal information will not be passed on to third parties, in particular to the employer, except in the case of express consent or legal obligation.

4. Disclaimer
Use of the platform is voluntary and at your own risk. Psychological counseling is not a substitute for medical or psychotherapeutic treatment. Mindvise accepts no liability for direct or indirect consequences arising from the use of counseling services.

5. Code of conduct
Respectful, professional interaction is a prerequisite. Discrimination, insults or behavior that violates boundaries will not be tolerated. The advisors are entitled to terminate conversations in the event of inappropriate behavior.

6. Cancellation policy
Consultation appointments must be canceled at least 12 hours before the start. If an appointment is canceled later, up to 80% of the fee can be claimed as expenses, depending on the employer’s regulations.

7. Restrictions on use
Use is not suitable if:

* You are in an acute mental health crisis or emergency. In such cases, please contact the medical on-call service (116117) or the emergency number 112.
* You have a serious mental illness that requires continuous specialist care.
* You are a minor and do not have the consent of your legal guardian.

If you are currently undergoing psychotherapeutic treatment, we recommend that you consult with your treating specialist before using the platform.

8. Consent to data processing
By using the platform, you agree to the terms of use and the privacy policy. You agree that your voluntarily submitted information on mental stress may be processed by Mindvise (including health data in accordance with Art. 9 GDPR). This consent is voluntary and can be revoked at any time.

If you have any questions or concerns, please contact:
[kontakt@mindvise.de](mailto:kontakt@mindvise.de)

Privacy policy

1. General information on data protection

Thank you for using our services. The protection of your personal data is important to us. This privacy policy explains how we process personal data, when you use our services. We only collect the data that is necessary for the use of our platform, and do not pass it on to third parties without your consent.

2. Person responsible for data processing

Responsible within the meaning of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR):

Mindvise
Pascal Seitz
Lamprecht Str. 51
63739 Aschaffenburg, Germany

Phone: 01579-2526192
E-mail: kontakt@mindvise.de
Website: https://mental.mindvise.de

3. Collection and use of personal data

We only collect the data provided by you (first name, e-mail address, telephone number, business code, consultation topic, additional information transmitted on the consultation request) that was transmitted when booking consultation appointments. This data is stored on our server for 30 days and then backed up locally for 12 months. Our freelance consultants receive your data when an appointment is booked and also store it locally for a maximum of 12 months. For service agreements with a limit on monthly consultations per employee, the data is used to monitor compliance with the set limits.

4. Booking via hotline

As an alternative to online booking, you have the option of booking appointments via the hotline listed above so that you do not have to enter any data via the booking system.

5. Voluntariness of use

Use of the advisory services via the platform is voluntary. There are no disadvantages if you do not wish to take advantage of the offer.

6. Legal basis of the processing

Your data is processed on the following legal bases:

  • Consent (Art. 6 para. 1 lit. a GDPR): Your voluntary consent when providing the data for booking appointments.
  • Fulfillment of a contract (Art. 6 para. 1 lit. b GDPR): Processing of data for the provision of our services.
  • Protection of legitimate interests (Art. 6 para. 1 lit. f GDPR): Data processing is carried out in the interest of the smooth operation of our services, provided that no interests of the data subject worthy of protection prevail.

7. Processing of special categories of data

As part of the consultation, information may be processed that allows conclusions to be drawn about your mental health (e.g. through free text information on stress or concerns). This data is considered special categories of personal data within the meaning of Art. 9 GDPR. The processing takes place exclusively with your express consent in accordance with Art. 9 para. 2 lit. a GDPR. This consent is voluntary and can be revoked at any time.

8. Video communication

For video communication, we recommend using Jitsi Meet on our server at https://meet.mindvise.de. Advisors are free to decide whether to use this server or choose an alternative platform, which will be communicated to you in advance by e-mail. In this case, the data protection provisions of the chosen provider apply. If you do not wish to use an alternative provider as a video communication tool, you can communicate this by sending an e-mail to the selected consultant in advance. When using the Mindvise-hosted Jitsi Meet instance, personal data such as IP addresses may be collected. This data is used exclusively to enable communication and is not passed on to third parties.

9. Mental Health Assistent (ChatGPT API)

When using the digital mental health assistant, your voluntary free text entries can be transmitted to the OpenAI API for processing. The processing is pseudonymized (without direct name or identity assignment) and exclusively for the provision of the assistant function. The transfer is secured by the conclusion of standard contractual clauses in accordance with Art. 46 GDPR and OpenAI’s participation in the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework.

10. Technical and organizational measures (TOMs)

We have implemented the following measures to ensure the protection of your data:

  • Access control: The servers are provided by ISO-certified providers (Netcup, Alfahosting).
  • Access control: Access is only granted via password-protected systems with strict password guidelines.
  • Encryption and data backup: All data transmissions are SSL-encrypted. Data is deleted every 30 days and backed up locally.
  • Forwarding control: Encrypted communication channels (e-mail, SSL) are used.
  • Separation control: Logical separation of test and production data.
  • Integrity control: Regular backups and version controls ensure data integrity.
  • Roles and rights system: Administrative access is restricted; there is no access to personal content.

11 Rights of the data subjects

You have the right, to request information about the personal data stored about you at any time and to request the correction, deletion or restriction of the processing of this data. You also have the right to data portability and the right to object. You can withdraw your consent to the processing of personal data at any time.

12. Right to erasure (“right to be forgotten”)

You have the right to request the deletion of your personal data if:

  • the data is no longer required for the original purpose;
  • You withdraw your consent and there is no other legal basis for processing;
  • You object to the processing and there are no overriding legitimate grounds;
  • the data was processed unlawfully;
  • the deletion is necessary to fulfill a legal obligation.

13. Right to lodge a complaint with the supervisory authority

If you believe that the processing of your data violates the GDPR, you have the right to lodge a complaint with the competent data protection authority:

The Bavarian State Commissioner for Data Protection
P.O. Box 22 12 19, 80502 Munich
E-mail: poststelle@datenschutz-bayern.de

14. Duration of data storage

Personal data is stored on our server for a maximum of 30 days. At the end of this period, the data is deleted and backed up locally. Freelance consultants store the data locally for up to 12 months and then delete it permanently.

15. Data transfer to third parties and third countries

We do not pass on personal data to third parties without your consent. Personal data is only transferred to third countries in the context of using the Mental Health Assistant. In this case, the transfer is secured by OpenAI’s participation in the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework and by standard contractual clauses (SCCs) in accordance with Art. 46 GDPR.

16. Cookies and similar technologies

We only use technically necessary cookies on our website to enable you to make optimum use of our services. Analytical or marketing cookies are not used.

17. Automated decision-making including profiling

There is no automated decision-making or profiling within the meaning of Art. 22 GDPR.

18. Further processing for other purposes

Further processing of the personal data collected for other purposes is not planned. Should this become necessary in the future, you will be informed accordingly prior to such further processing.

19. Time of provision of the information

This information is provided to you at the latest at the time of data collection and within one month of the data being collected.

20. Adjustments to this privacy policy

We reserve the right to amend this privacy policy if necessary, to comply with legal requirements or to reflect changes to our services.